A New Retirement Planning Opportunity
The SECURE 2.0 Act introduced a significant enhancement to employer-sponsored retirement plans: the ability for participants to elect Roth treatment for certain employer contributions. Prior to SECURE 2.0, employees could make Roth elective deferrals to a 401(k) or 403(b) plan provided that the Plan Document allowed for Roth elective deferrals, but employer matching and nonelective contributions were required to be made on a pre-tax basis. Section 604 of SECURE 2.0 changed that rule.
Effective for contributions made after December 29, 2022, employers may allow participants to designate certain employer matching and nonelective contributions as Roth contributions. This provision applies to 401(k), 403(b), and governmental 457(b) plans provided that the Plan Sponsor wishes to adopt a Roth employer contribution provision into their Plan Document.
How Roth Employer Contributions Work
Under SECURE 2.0, employees may elect to have eligible employer contributions treated as Roth contributions at the time they are allocated to their accounts if the Plan Document allows. Unlike traditional employer contributions, Roth employer contributions are included in the employee's taxable income in the year contributed. In exchange, qualified future distributions—including earnings—can potentially be received tax-free provided that the contributions follow the normal Roth rules.
Examples of eligible contributions include:
Safe harbor matching or nonelective contributions
Nonelective (Profit Sharing) employer contributions
Discretionary matching contributions
Key Requirements
1. Contributions Must Be Fully Vested
One of the most important limitations is that only fully vested (nonforfeitable) employer contributions may be designated as Roth contributions. If an employee is not 100% vested in the employer contribution when it is made, the contribution cannot be treated as Roth.
2. Election Must Be Made Before Allocation
Employees must make an irrevocable election before the employer contribution is allocated to their account. Once the contribution is designated as Roth and allocated, the election cannot be reversed.
3. Opportunity to Change Elections
Plans that offer Roth employer contributions must allow participants to make or change their election at least once each plan year for future contributions.
4. Separate Accounting
Like Roth salary deferrals, Roth employer contributions must be maintained in separately accounted Roth accounts (e.g., a new source code) within the retirement plan.
Tax Treatment
The primary distinction between traditional and Roth employer contributions is the timing of taxation.
Traditional Employer Contributions
Not taxable when contributed
Grow tax-deferred
Taxable upon distribution
Roth Employer Contributions
Taxable in the year contributed
Future qualified distributions are generally tax-free
Investment earnings may also be distributed tax-free if Roth requirements are met
IRS guidance indicates that Roth employer contributions are reported similarly to in-plan Roth rollovers using Form 1099-R reporting rules.
Employer Considerations
Although SECURE 2.0 permits Roth employer contributions, employers are not required to offer them. Plan sponsors can choose whether to allow:
Roth matching contributions
Roth nonelective contributions
Both types of Roth employer contributions
Neither type, even if Roth employee deferrals are already available
Before implementing the feature, employers should consider:
Recordkeeping system capabilities
Payroll and tax reporting requirements
Participant education and communication needs
Administrative complexity related to vesting and elections
Potential Benefits for Employees
Roth employer contributions may be attractive to employees who:
Expect to be in a higher tax bracket during retirement
Want greater tax diversification
Prefer paying taxes now rather than later
Anticipate substantial long-term investment growth within the plan
For younger workers and high-income savers who believe tax rates could increase in the future, the Roth option may provide meaningful retirement income planning flexibility. Of course, this should be considered within the overall financial and tax plan of the participant. Participants are encouraged to discuss with a tax professional.
Current Market Adoption
While the provision became effective in late 2022, adoption has been gradual. Many plan sponsors and recordkeepers waited for IRS guidance before implementing the feature. IRS Notice 2024-2, released in December 2023, provided much-needed clarification regarding election requirements, vesting rules, taxation, and reporting.
As recordkeeping platforms continue to expand functionality and participants become more familiar with the option, Roth employer contributions are expected to become increasingly common. Currently, however, major recordkeepers have yet to offer the capability.
Conclusion
SECURE 2.0's Roth employer contribution provision represents one of the most significant Roth expansions in recent retirement plan legislation. By allowing employees to elect Roth treatment for fully vested matching and nonelective contributions, Congress has given plan participants another tool to manage future tax liabilities and build tax-free retirement income. Employers considering adoption should work closely with their Retirement Plan Consultant (like here at Evergreen), recordkeepers, and financial advisor to the plan to evaluate administrative requirements and participant demand before implementing the feature.